Auto lenders today operate in a landscape defined by unprecedented market volatility and converging pressures. Exacerbated by pandemic-era lending practices and the acceleration of negative equity, the average size of personal auto loans has increased more than 20% since 2023, with consumers taking on more debt for their vehicles.
When combined, these environmental factors create what lenders call a triple crunch consisting of rising acquisition costs, increased risk to the borrower, and shrinking margins.
These trends underscore the growing importance of a proactive partnership between lenders and borrowers, with a renewed focus on peace of mind and strategic risk mitigation.
Affordability pressures are reshaping borrower behavior long before default occurs. Auto insurance premiums have increased about 55% since February 2020, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Parts, repairs and maintenance have also increased significantly, raising the total cost of ownership to levels that make even routine vehicle expenses difficult to absorb.
Still, the purchase price of vehicles is the biggest factor in the contraction. Inflation, supply constraints, cross-border tariffs and rising production costs have all contributed to this. TruStage research on consumer lending shows that as borrowers take on larger balances and face increasing monthly payments, lenders see a broader increase in loan delinquencies and financial stress. Credit union leaders have told me personally that they have seen a marked increase in voluntary repossessions, where overwhelmed consumers are proactively turning in their cars, unable to bear the financial burden.
Portfolio data reflects this reality. NCUA results show that delinquency balances nearly doubled between 2020 and 2024, rising from $1.9 billion to $4.6 billion before declining slightly in 2025. At the same time, 9 in 10 consumers tell us that an unexpected event in their life could disrupt their ability to pay, reflecting a deeper sense of financial vulnerability.
With borrowing costs rising on the front end, borrower resilience weakening in the middle, and margin pressure intensifying across portfolios, lenders find themselves in the middle of a triple squeeze.
Debt patterns reflect this reality: Americans now owe a record $1.66 trillion in auto loan debt, making it the second-largest category of consumer debt after mortgages. TruStage research found that the average auto loan size increased more than 20% from 2023 to 2025; now at $41,000. For many households, that payment competes directly with rent, food and medical bills.
When budgets tighten, options change. Borrowers delay purchases, look for smaller or older vehicles, or look to refinance to lower payments. These adaptations are not signs of temporary discomfort. They are indicators of a restoration of long-term affordability.
Larger loan amounts and more financially fragile borrowers mean that each loan approval comes with greater exposure than just a few years ago. A great auto loan is no longer a one-time underwriting decision. It becomes a long-term commitment that requires constant monitoring and continuous support to borrowers. Higher balances are more difficult for consumers to manage month after month and result in greater losses for the lender if delinquencies occur.
Compounding this problem, many lenders still operate with underwriting frameworks designed for a very different rate and affordability environment. These guidelines were created when vehicle prices were lower, loan terms were shorter, and household savings were stronger. Today’s borrowers often need longer terms, flexible payment structures, or temporary relief options to stay afloat financially. When financial institutions’ standards for acceptable terms or rates cannot adapt to consumer realities, the risk of default increases.
High prices for vehicles and other goods cause consumers to carry more debt. Our own research found that 34% of consumers are using credit cards to cover rising costs, and the Federal Reserve reports that delinquencies on auto loans and credit card debt have reached levels not seen since the Great Financial Crisis.
Lenders are feeling the pressure on their own balance sheets. For many credit unions and community institutions, financing costs have increased by approximately 235 to 287 basis points in recent years, especially as the simultaneously rising cost of risk comes from more delinquencies, more repossessions, and greater severity of losses.
When the cost of funds and the cost of risk rise at the same time, spreads quickly compress and the strain becomes visible throughout the credit cycle, from origination to servicing.
Ultimately, servicing teams are experiencing the aftereffects: More borrowers are applying for extensions, hardship programs or refinancing, but often only after missing a payment.
Once delinquency occurs, both financial and operational difficulty in resolving it increases. These patterns reinforce a critical conclusion for lenders: Intervention must happen sooner, and institutions need tools that make it easier for borrowers to seek help before temporary stress turns into default.
The pressures facing both consumers and auto lenders are clear. As macroeconomic factors and structural changes continue to reshape the market, the most important question is how institutions can mitigate default risk and provide borrowers with greater peace of mind. To lessen the triple pressure, a number of strategies emerge for lenders as they work to improve borrower stability long before loan delinquencies appear.
-
Proactive portfolio management: Monitoring early-stage payment behavior, insurance trends and liquidity indicators allows lenders to identify risk earlier, get there sooner and reduce downstream losses. Additionally, by integrating behavioral and transactional data, lenders can achieve earlier, more accurate visibility into risk and tailor support to individual borrower needs.
-
Innovative Lending Solutions and Integrated Protection: Borrowers seek stability and peace of mind in their loan contracts. Although 80% of consumers indicated they would choose loan protection on their next loan, only 54% remember being offered these options. Integrated protection solutions are essential in the current environment, providing support during unexpected difficulties and strengthening trust between lender and borrower.
-
Leverage data analytics to improve risk assessment: The rise of digital and mobile lending apps provides real-time insights into borrower preferences and resilience. By integrating behavioral and transactional data, lenders can achieve earlier, more accurate visibility into risk and tailor support to individual borrower needs.
-
Empower borrowers with flexible options: Consumers increasingly value refinancing avenues, unique loan structures and enhanced digital resources. Flexible payment arrangements and transparent hardship programs strengthen borrower confidence, helping households stay in their vehicles during short-term shocks and reducing the overall risk of delinquency.
The triple contraction is more than a temporary recession. It’s a structural change that will shape auto lending for years to come. Rising loan sizes, increased borrower fragility, and margin compression are converging to test even the strongest portfolios.
Lenders cannot manage tomorrow’s risks with yesterday’s playbooks, requiring institutions to prioritize solutions that enhance the resilience and stability of both lenders and borrowers.
Those who act now will not only overcome the triple pressure, but will also help define what sustainable, borrower-centered lending will look like in the next decade.
Corrin Maier, vice president of lending at TruStage
“Navigating the Triple Contraction” was created and originally published by Retail Banker International, a brand owned by GlobalData.
The information contained on this site has been included in good faith for general information purposes only. It is not intended to be advice on which you should rely, and we make no representations or warranties, whether express or implied, as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action based on the content on our site.
