Exchange-traded funds have earned their place in retirement portfolios because they are diversified, low-cost, and easy to manage. For retirees who don’t want to spend their mornings picking stocks, ETFs like the Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF (NYSE:SCHD) or the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (NYSE:VYM) offer instant access to hundreds of dividend-paying companies in a single holding. It’s the easiest path to income, and for many investors, this is where the conversation ends.
-
Schwab Dividend ETF (SCHD) 3.32% yield, Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) 2.28%, Enterprise Products Partners (EPD) 5.92%, Realty Income (O) 4.91%, Procter & Gamble (PG) 2.67%, PepsiCo (PEP) 3.47%, JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI).
-
Broad dividend ETFs dilute better performers with weaker holdings, so adding individual high-yielding stocks to an ETF base boosts income and growth.
-
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks. Get them here for FREE.
But simplicity comes with a cost that most retirees never examine: When you own a broad dividend ETF, you keep all the companies in that fund’s index, including those with thin margins, unstable cash flow, or already tight payout ratios. The fund averages everything together, meaning the strong dividend producers in the portfolio are being diluted by the weaker ones. The result is lower performance than would be achieved by directly and selectively owning the best companies, and a slower growth rate than the individual top payers can achieve on their own.
This doesn’t mean ETFs are wrong for most investors – far from it – but it could mean they’re incomplete for retirees who want to maximize their income without taking on unnecessary risks. Adding a layer of carefully selected individual dividend stocks alongside your ETF holdings can boost returns, increase income growth, and give you a level of control over your cash flow that no fund can replicate. For a generation of investors who were taught to avoid stock picking altogether, this is the layer of income they are leaving on the table.
READ: The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named its top 10 AI stocks
The Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF has over 570 stocks and is currently yielding 2.28% with an annual payout of $3.50 per share. Additionally, you can check out the Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF (NYSE:SCHD), which is more selective with only 101 holdings, but still yields only 3.32% with an annual payout of $1.05. Both are solid funds, but the returns reflect the average of all holdings, including companies with returns of 1% or less that are dragging them down.
Now, switch gears for a moment and compare these two ETFs to what’s possible when you’re outside the fund’s wrapper. Enterprise Products Partners (NYSE:EPD) offers a dividend yield of 5.92% and an annual dividend of $2.20 and has increased its payout for 28 consecutive years. Similarly, Realty Income (NYSE:O), one of the best names in the REIT space, pays monthly with a 4.91% yield and an annual dividend of $3.24 and has increased its payout every year for 22 years. The most important consideration is that these are not obscure, speculative names, but they are among the most widely held income stocks on the market and generate significantly more cash than the ETFs that partially own them.
When you own an ETF, you can’t decide which companies stay and which go, as the fund follows its own index methodology, and if a holding cuts its dividend or begins to show signs of financial deterioration, it remains in the portfolio until the next rebalancing date. You are in the way and have no say in whether a weakened position continues to take up space in your income plan.
Owning individual stocks puts that decision in your hands, because you can select companies based on the metrics that matter most to income investors. This will include payout ratio, free cash flow coverage, consecutive years of dividend increases, and sector exposure.
You can now create a portfolio in which each position has been individually examined for durability. If something changes, you can act immediately instead of waiting for a committee to update an index. For retirees whose income depends on every dollar arriving on time, this level of control is not a luxury, but rather a practical advantage.
One of the most overlooked benefits of owning individual dividend stocks is the ability to target companies with exceptional growth rates that get muted within a fund. Procter & Gamble (NYSE:PG) has increased its dividend for 70 consecutive years, paying out a 2.67% yield and a payout of $4.23. PepsiCo (NASDAQ:PEP) is another opportunity for investors, earning a dividend yield of 3.47% with an annual payout of $5.69 and experiencing dividend growth of 4.98% each year. They are known as “Dividend Kings”, companies with half a century or more of uninterrupted increases.
Within an ETF, its growth is averaged with that of all other holdings in the fund, including companies that have frozen or barely increased their payouts. On their own, these stocks generate income that compounds at rates far higher than any broad fund can offer. An investor who buys PepsiCo today for its 3.47% yield and sees 5% dividend growth will make a lot of money on their original investment over the next decade, without adding a single new dollar of capital.
This type of acceleration of performance over costs is almost impossible to achieve through a fund that rebalances around an index every quarter.
The goal is not to abandon ETFs, but to treat them as a base and use individual stocks as an income accelerator. A practical approach is to keep 60% to 70% of your income allocation in diversified ETFs like the Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF or the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (NYSE:JEPI) for broad exposure and monthly cash flow, then allocate the remaining 30% to 40% among five to ten individual holdings selected specifically for higher yield or dividend growth.
A retiree investing $500,000 in this structure could hold $325,000 in ETFs, with a combined return of 5%, and $175,000 in individual stocks, with a return of another 5.5%, and generate approximately $25,875 a year from the individual positions they hold separately. That’s over $2,100 a month from a focused group of businesses chosen for meeting specific income criteria.
The bottom line is that the base of the ETF will keep you diversified, while the individual layer gives you performance, growth, and control that no fund can offer on its own. Together, you can create an income strategy that is stronger than either approach alone.
Wall Street is investing billions in AI, but most investors are buying the wrong stocks. The analyst who first identified NVIDIA as a buyback in 2010, before its 28,000% run, just identified 10 AI startups that he thinks could generate huge returns from here. One dominates an equipment market valued at $100 billion. Another is solving the biggest bottleneck holding back AI data centers. A third is a pure play in an optical networking market that will quadruple. Most investors haven’t heard of half of these names. Get the free list of 10 stocks here.
