Is CPRT a good stock to buy? We found a bullish thesis on Copart, Inc. in The Fat Pitch Substack. In this article we will summarize the bulls’ thesis on CPRT. Copart, Inc. stock was trading at $33.74 on April 21. CPRT’s trailing and forward P/E were 21.23 and 20.04 respectively, according to Yahoo Finance.
Photo by Paolo Resteghini on Unsplash
Copart (CPRT) operates as the dominant player in the global salvage auction industry, and its most powerful competitive advantage comes from owning approximately 90% of its land, a scarce and highly strategic resource required to store wrecked vehicles during the auction process. Unlike competitors like IAA, which relies heavily on long-term leased yards with renewal cycles, CPRT’s ownership model eliminates recurring rental expenses and materially reshapes its cost structure.
Read more: 15 AI Stocks That Are Quietly Making Investors Rich
Read more: Undervalued AI Stocks Poised for Massive Gains: 10000% Upgrade Potential
This structural difference explains why CPRT has consistently generated operating margins of over 30% and a 10-year average of approximately 36%, an exceptional level for an industrial-type business. Lease-based models, such as IAA, incur ongoing rental obligations and shorter depreciation schedules for improvements, while CPRT capitalizes land on its balance sheet and depreciates only buildings and equipment over a period of 15 to 39 years, significantly reducing annual expenses.
Adjusting CPRT’s financials as if 100% of the land were leased, the implied core operating margin remains strong at approximately 28%, but this reveals that nearly 1,000 basis points of margin advantage are directly attributable to its land ownership strategy. Even after normalization, CPRT continues to outperform IAA, which has averaged around 22% operating margins over five years. Beyond accounting effects, cash flow quality is superior as land purchases convert inflation-hedged real assets into retained earnings, while lease payments permanently exit the system.
This structure also incorporates a hedge against inflation, as CPRT’s land cost is historically fixed while rental markets continually increase, unlike IAA, which must absorb increased lease renewals regardless of economic cycles. As a result, CPRT’s moat worsens over time as land scarcity intensifies, reinforcing both pricing power and long-term free cash flow resilience. Overall, this structural advantage continues to widen the gap against competitors and positions CPRT as a durable, high-quality compound with lasting shareholder value creation.