A TikTok by @sreela.r showing anxious travelers getting off an Emirates plane went viral after news broke of a surprise $100,000 fee tied to new H-1B petitions. The clip captured private panic in public view as workers wondered if their jobs, start dates and long-planned moves had been canceled at the stroke of a pen.
Indian news outlet NDTV reported disembarkations and delays while video showed confused and stressed families hurriedly grabbing their belongings to leave the plane. (1)
Behind the human drama of disrupted plans lie serious political concerns about how the H-1B visa program is being used (and abused). H-1B visas allow foreign workers with highly specialized skills to enter the US and work. The debate has pitted political factions against each other and united former workers.
Supporters of President Trump’s measure see it as a way to protect American jobs. Critics see it as an unforced economic shock that could halt hiring and reduce American competitiveness, especially in technology and artificial intelligence.
The temporary H-1B visa for “skilled occupation” positions was created in 1990 by Congress to help companies recruit talent from abroad and fill hard-to-find skilled jobs while protecting American wages. The visa is initially granted for up to three years and can be extended to six.
Congress set an annual limit of 65,000 new visas, with an additional 20,000 spots for graduates of American master’s programs. Employers, not workers, file the petition and must pay the required fees. Approvals, including renewals, peaked in 2022, at 442,425. (2)
More than 70% of new H-1B approvals go to Indian professionals. Chinese citizens are the next largest group, making up 10% of the total. For years, employers have recruited H-1B candidates from India and China for staffing projects, arguing that domestic hiring alone cannot fill high-tech positions that rely on these workers.
In late 2024, former Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy faced backlash for claiming that American culture values ”mediocrity over excellence,” which he claimed was the reason technology companies rely heavily on H-1B visas. (3)
H-1B workers are concentrated in computing and engineering occupations, most commonly within the professional, scientific, and technical services sector. USCIS reports that this sector accounted for approximately half of approved beneficiaries in 2024, with the remainder spread across manufacturing, finance, healthcare, and higher education.
Large technology, consulting and financial companies are frequent petitioners. Among the main sponsors are Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Meta, Apple, large consulting companies, financial institutions and universities.
Read more: US auto insurance costs increased 50% between 2020 and 2024; This Simple 2-Minute Check Could Put Hundreds of Dollars Back in Your Pocket
H-1B visas have become particularly controversial in the 21st century as the program has expanded alongside Big Tech’s push to reduce costs and the offshoring of highly skilled labor.
Federal watchdogs have warned that a small proportion of companies get a large share of approvals. Indian staffing giants such as Cognizant Technology Solutions, Tata Consultancy Services and Infosys are among the biggest recipients. Three of the top 10 H-1B employers in 2023 were based in or originated in India, up from six in 2016.
Tech leaders argue that the United States faces a persistent shortage of STEM skills and that attracting global talent is essential for innovation, a view shared by Elon Musk and Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, both former H-1B visa holders. (4) Top CEOs, including Apple’s Tim Cook, Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, former Google CEO Eric Schmidt and Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg, have called for the program to be expanded.
Critics respond that corporations exploit the system to reduce labor costs. Employment agencies sometimes submit multiple applications for the same worker under different employers to increase your chances of winning a visa in the lottery. (5)
A Bloomberg report found that these staffing companies often pay lower wages to visa holders and exclude more qualified candidates. (6) The Economic Policy Institute found that most H-1B employers pay migrant workers below market rates and that many H-1B workers hesitate to report workplace abuses for fear of losing their visas. (7) This dynamic lowers the salaries of local workers between 17% and 34% on average.
Unfortunately, the H1-B problem has been decades in the making. While the original goal of attracting foreign talent undeniably fueled American innovation, reliance on low-cost skilled labor has made it difficult for American companies to cultivate local talent. Training in advanced artificial intelligence, chip design, cybersecurity and specialized software is no longer limited to American universities or research centers.
There is no quick or equitable solution to the H1-B problem. A sudden $100,000 fee on new requests adds significant friction to hiring highly qualified people. And while the clarifications have softened the immediate shock, companies and workers still face higher costs, tighter deadlines and more difficult choices about where to do critical work.
Reversing the imbalances created during the first quarter of the 21st century will take time and could have unintended consequences.
Join over 200,000 readers and get the best Moneywise exclusive stories and interviews first – clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.
We rely only on verified sources and credible third-party reports. For more information, see our editorial guidelines and ethics.
NDTV (1); Bank investigation (2); KATV (3); Business insider information (4); Bloomberg (5); Berkeley University (6); PAI (7).
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
